Unlike a pension that promises a fixed amount for life, a defined contribution pension plan places more responsibility on your clients. They build a pool of savings over their career rather than earning a pre-set monthly pension. That structure changes the kind of conversations you need to have about contributions, investment risk, and what to do with the money when employment ends.
In this article, Wealth Professional Canada will explore everything you need to know about defined contribution pension plans. Want to read the latest defined contribution pension plan news? Scroll to the bottom to explore all that we've published!
A defined contribution pension plan is an employer-sponsored registered plan where the contributions are set in advance, but the retirement benefit is not. Your clients know how much goes into the plan. They do not know exactly how much income they will receive in retirement.
In most cases, the employer and the employee both contribute a percentage of the employee's earnings. Contributions are usually taken straight from each paycheque and deposited into an individual account for the member. Investment earnings are credited to that account over time.
The retirement income that a defined contribution pension plan can support depends on these two factors:
There is no formula that promises a certain amount based on years of service and salary, as you would see in a defined benefit pension. Instead, the balance in the account at retirement is the starting point for any income strategy. This is why your clients might find it hard to predict their future pension income with precision. Watch this video to learn more about defined contribution pension plans:
When you discuss defined contribution pension plans with your clients, link the conversation to the trend of Canadians delaying retirement. Explain how access to pension income impacts their sense of financial security and influences their choices about when to stop working.
In a defined contribution pension plan, the employer usually sets a fixed contribution rate as a percentage of earnings. The employer is required to contribute at least one percent of the member's earnings and cannot go over the annual maximum for defined contribution plans in a given year.
Many plans are designed so that your clients contribute a portion of their salary. The employer then matches some or all of that contribution up to a limit.
In practice, this match can be one of the most valuable features of a defined contribution pension plan. If your clients do not contribute at least up to the match level, they are leaving part of their compensation unused.
A defined contribution pension plan can be a useful savings structure, but it is not without drawbacks. As a financial advisor, you need to prepare your clients for the risks that come with this type of plan.
Here are three disadvantages of defined contribution pension plans:
1. No guaranteed retirement income
2. Investment risk falls on your clients
3. Need for active management and ongoing review
Let's further discuss each disadvantage below:
The most visible disadvantage is the lack of a guaranteed pension. With a defined benefit plan, members expect a specific income based on service and pay. Also, the employer takes on the responsibility for funding that promise. In a defined contribution pension plan, there is no such promise.
Your clients' retirement income comes from the account balance they have built plus the strategy they use to draw income in retirement. If investment returns are weak or if they do not contribute enough, the pension income that results might be lower than they hoped.
There is also the risk that your clients live longer than an initial projection. Since there is no built-in lifetime guarantee, poor withdrawal choices or unexpected longevity can result in their savings being used up sooner than planned.
Another disadvantage is the transfer of investment risk. In a defined contribution pension plan, your clients decide how to invest their contributions within the plan menu.
Poor fund selection, a mismatch between risk tolerance and asset mix, or a lack of ongoing review can all affect the outcome. Market downturns can reduce the account value, especially if your clients are heavily invested in more volatile assets near retirement.
A defined contribution pension plan does not shield them from these market movements. Instead, they must accept that returns will vary and adjust their contribution levels and investment choices accordingly.
Defined contribution pension plans require your clients to put in more effort. They must decide on contribution rates, review paycheque deductions, and reassess their investments as life changes.
At a minimum, you can encourage your clients to:
Without this ongoing attention, a defined contribution pension plan might not deliver the retirement income your clients expect. This can happen even if the structure of the plan is sound.
Check out this clip to further understand the disadvantages of defined contribution pension plans:
The best financial advisors in Canada know how to maximize defined contribution pension plans. They can also help their clients dodge the drawbacks listed above.
Your clients often compare their defined contribution pension plan with a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) because both involve tax-deferred retirement savings. While there are similarities, the two are not the same.
Both a defined contribution pension plan and an RRSP involve setting aside money for retirement and investing it for growth. Employee contributions to a defined contribution pension plan reduce taxable income in much the same way as RRSP contributions.
Tax on investment growth inside both types of accounts is deferred until money is withdrawn, usually later in life when income might be lower.
In a defined contribution pension plan, your clients have control over how their contributions are invested within the choices offered by the employer's provider. This is similar in spirit to an RRSP, where the investor chooses their own investments.
In both cases, the amount available in retirement depends on contributions and returns.
There are important differences that you need to highlight in conversations with your clients:
The employer sets the plan rules, arranges payroll deductions and contributes their share. An RRSP is an individual account set up directly by your clients with a financial institution.
There is no automatic employer match inside an RRSP unless it is part of a separate group arrangement.
What happens when the combined contributions to a defined contribution pension plan trigger a pension adjustment? It reduces fresh RRSP room for the next year.
Your clients cannot simply treat their defined contribution pension plan and RRSP as separate silos without thinking about their interaction. This is because the tax system is designed to keep overall tax-assisted savings within certain limits.
Defined contribution pension plans are registered as pension plans and must follow pension legislation. This often means that the money is locked in for retirement.
When your clients leave an employer or retire, they usually cannot just withdraw the entire balance in cash. Instead, the funds move into other locked-in structures or are used to buy retirement income products.
An RRSP is more flexible in that sense. Withdrawals can occur at any time, subject to tax. There is no locking in under pension rules. However, that flexibility can be a risk if your clients draw down too much before retirement.
Overall, you can describe a defined contribution pension plan as a structured, workplace-based version of tax-deferred saving. It shares some features with an RRSP but has its own contribution, locking in and transfer rules.
Defined contribution pension plans are becoming an important source of retirement income for many Canadians. For you as a financial advisor, they change the nature of retirement planning conversations with your clients. Instead of working with a fixed pension promise, you are helping your clients manage a pool of savings.
With defined contribution pension plans, your clients will take on more investment and longevity risk than with a traditional defined benefit pension. Their choices over time directly impact the retirement income they receive.
Still, these plans offer real advantages your clients can use. Employer contributions, tax-deferred growth, and structured saving through payroll can support stronger retirement outcomes when used wisely.
When all these pieces work together, a defined contribution pension plan can become a stable part of your clients' retirement income mix. It can support the long-term financial security they are working toward.
Experts believe the digital tool would help Canadians keep on top of retirement planning
Discover how a Desjardins group RRSP can support employees. Learn key features and benefits, tax advantages, and investment strategies in this guide
Professor of risk management and filmmaker outlines why modern circumstances mean Canadians are woefully underprepared for how long they might live
Recent surveys report more than half of Canadians feel they are behind on retirement savings and do not put enough money away
A new report calls for 30-year-old rules to be updated to avoid tax-deferred savings shortfall
Research suggests that even working a few hours a week will help prevent retirement savings running dry
More Canadians to access innovative retirement solution through best-in-class DC plan platform
New partnership allows PMs and financial advisors to access proprietary digital platform for their clients' benefit
Clients with busy employment histories face risks from lack of tax planning and risk management
A significant portion of those approaching retirement expect hardships ahead
